We get started by gently mixing a Table Spoon of the Meat Church Honey Hog BBQ and a Teaspoon of the Traeger Saskatchewan Rub. Once it is all mixed together, just let that sit and marinade while we get our veggies prepped.
New Paragraph
Now, let's dice half of each Onion and mix them into a bowl. Then we will dice each of the Bell Pepper halves and mix them up nicely, followed by dicing our Jalapeño, and finely chop a few heads of Garlic. The Jalapeño is optional, and you can add or subtract Garlic to your liking (I prefer quite a bit). Bonus Tip: if you slice off the basic plate (hard end), place the cloves into a metal container such as a bar shaker, shake vigorously, they will all but peel themselves.
At this point, I like to stage everything near the pan for easy access and quick delivery. I like to melt a tablespoon or so of Butter into the skillet with an equal tablespoon of Canola Oil to get the pad ready.
First thing we need to do is get all the Onions and Peppers good a caramelized, nice and soft. Sauté them until nice and tender, probably about 5 or 6 minutes, maybe a bit more depending on how much you have in there. At this point you are probably thinking, are we eating a salad or a Sloppy Joe? That is a lot of veggies, do I need tthat much? Probably not, you could do a lot less if you wanted, but Trust me, the next step will probably blow your mind, might just freak you out, but it is soo worth it.
So, YES, that is a LOT of veggies, so to help with flavor and thickness, I'm going to take about a third of those soft, tender, delicious veggies and blend them into a slurry to put back into the pan as a thickening agent.
Now, pour the puréed veggie slurry back into the pan and toss in your chopped garlic. Mix that all up and cook until aromatic, maybe 40 seconds, maybe less.
Once the Garlic starts to smell, add in the Ground Chuck and cook everything together until the Ground Chuck fully cooked. When you got your Chuck done, throw in your Tomato Sauce and mix everything together, top that with the remaining ingredients (3/4th ish cups of Jalapeño ketchup, a couple tablespoons of Brown Sugar, a Tablespoon or so of the Yellow Mustard, perhaps a tablespoon of the Paprika, and a teaspoon or so of the Cayenne Pepper. Grind in your Salt and Pepper and let that all simmer for 20 minutes or so until it is the thickness you prefer. Although we all appreciate a good SLOPPY Joe, nobody likes a soggy bun.
Some days are better than others and today, the sauce was just not reducing to where I prefer it. When that happens, there are probably a thousand methods for thickening it back up ... some folks talk about a Flour slurry (it's never a good idea to add flour at the end of cooking, flour needs quite a bit of time to cook out properly), there are those that subscribe to the Cornstarch slurry (not a bad slurry, but it doesn't add anything but thickness), if you need to add something in, why not put in a little flavor while you are at it? Some folks use Oats, which is nice, but if you have leftovers, the oats will continue to soak up the sauce and tomorrow you might have to add sauce to get it back to where you like it. There are those that add Mashed Potatoes, ok, but that seems like a lot of extra work .. Personally, I just add about 1/4 of a cup of mashed potato flakes, much easier that making mashed potatoes first, and I almost always have a box on hand to use to thicken all kinds of soups and sauces. Just add a little at a time util everything is the consistency you are looking for.
Once you got the Sloppy Joe exactly where you want it, toast up a couple of buns, toss on a slice of your favorite Cheese (Pepper Jack for me), maybe melt that cheese under the broiler, grab yourself a Cold Beverage and sit down and enjoy.
#NationalSloppyJoeDay